Why Evolution Cannot Explain Where Morality Comes From
FAVORITE PODCAST PLAYER https://podcast.chrissbiblenewsletter.org
Why Evolution Cannot Explain Where Morality Comes From
Darwinists claim that morality it’s merely a result of evolution. Helping one’s tribe survive and thrive meant that one’s genes would be more likely to survive and thrive, which is interesting.
So feeling the urge to be altruistic towards one tribe and to some degree other humans was advantageous.
While this may explain why we are inclined to be moral to some degree, it doesn’t explain why we ought to be moral.
So we’re going to be discussing morality here. Evolution tying these two things together. As always, each section builds on the next. Stick around till the end where we sort of wrap things up, tie it all together.
What Will You Learn Here Today?
Why the instinct to survive is not the same thing as the urge to morality.
How group selection can not explain objective morality.
Why philosophers what they mean by objective and subjective morality.
How the Bible explains morality better than evolution.
Why culture cannot be the root of universal moral codes.
Why the desire to cheat but feeling the ought not to cheat cannot come from evolution.
How the Bible explains where morality comes from.
So, we’re going to jump in get started here.
Part 1: Survival and Morality
What are we looking at? Survival. Morality.
Evolution can explain why organisms seek to survive. But survival is not the same as knowing, “I ought to do this.”
A survival instinct describes behavior. Morality makes a claim about what is right or wrong.
So, what’s survival instinct?
Evolution may explain why one wishes to be successful or healthy or prosperous and so on. It may explain why one ought to follow these desires as far as one’s genes, tribe, community, even one’s wish, right?
But morality, it’s not a want or a desire, but it is an ought.
I ought. This is what I ought to do.
We may find ourselves desiring to cheat on our partners, on our significant others, giving into different sexual desires. This makes us desire to satisfy them, right?
But it would not give us the idea that I ought to cheat on my partner, right?
So hopefully you can understand this.
Part 2: Objective and Subjective Morality
Now what is objective morality?
Objective morality and subjective morality. We talk about objective and subjective a lot on this channel.
Objective morality: Some actions are truly right or wrong. Even if a person or culture disagrees.
Subjective morality: Right or wrong depend on the individual beliefs, preferences or culture rules.
Evolutionists claim that morality is the result of group selection. As communities that cooperated tended to do better than those that didn’t.
Which that makes sense because what I would say is the community you’re in probably the majority of that community is sort of together.
I can’t say this for sure, but if you’re in a community living together, you’re probably living with people that you get along with, which means you probably all agree. There might be a small percentage that disagrees, which is normal.
If morality is explained by evolution, then what is considered moral is relative to the needs of the group for survival.
And we could just leave this right here.
Hopefully you’re understanding this that what is considered moral is relative to the needs of a group for survival.
So as our group evolves, let’s say we have a community and that community evolves, then maybe our needs change.
And as our needs change, right? Then with those changing needs, our morals are changing. And because of that, we are adjusting our morals.
Essentially, what is right or wrong based on our needs.
So that would be subjective. Subjective morality.
Whatever tends to improve the chances of a group surviving and thriving in a particular environment, this is then considered moral.
This is from evolutionists.
The practice of infanticide was common and even necessary in some environments as a means of population control.
Slavery was common and beneficial to many societies.
Genocide was a way to make room for more desirable groups that would thrive better in that given environment.
So if morality is merely whatever improves the chances of survival for groups, then these practices are moral.
But few people believe any of these practices are objectively moral in any environment because remember how could they be objectively moral if they’re changing based on the needs of the group and they’re changing the group to fit the moral needs of that group.
However, we all believe there is an objective morality that applies to all groups at all times.
Richard Dawkins, an evolutionist, prominent defender of the Darwinian perspective, which we talk about from time to time, realized that a problem existed in that data.
This didn’t quite fit.
In the book, The Selfish Gene, what did he say?
Evolutionary biology cannot explain objective morality for evolution has no objective aim or goal.
And this is interesting. Hold on to this as we keep moving down.
Part 3: Can Group Selection Explain Morality?
So group selection may help explain why cooperation can benefit a group, right?
But cooperation does not prove that cooperation is morally right.
And this makes perfect sense.
Evolution can describe why a behavior may have survived, not why we ought to do it.
So remember there’s an ought here. And there is a moral piece here.
Why Culture Cannot Be the Root of Morality
When it comes to group selection, if morality is based on culture, here’s the problem with this.
And I would love to hear your thoughts in the comments on this as well. Always keep it respectful. Please share. Someone will answer your comments if not me.
Most of the time it’s always good to encourage discussion, right? We’re all here to learn. We’re all here to grow.
Also too, before we move on, please click the subscribe button, like the video, share the video. All of these small metrics really do help.
We check our numbers and analytics. The more people that do this, it’s free. It takes a few seconds, gets the message out further and the content is viewed more.
So this works. So please subscribe and like the episode if you’re getting value here.
Some societies have held horrific moral codes, right?
If these moral codes are based on just culture, then there’s no objective right or wrong, just different opinions.
So here’s an example.
Nazis had a certain opinion of right and wrong and so did apartheid South Africa, the Soviet Union, other regimes of the past and present.
So what does this mean?
If different cultures have different rights and morals, then it isn’t wrong for anyone to hold any moral code that they themselves believe in.
Because essentially they’re going by their moral codes of that community.
Now you and I know those moral codes are completely wrong and completely off.
We are sure these regimes were wrong which demonstrate that there is indeed an objective right and wrong.
That does go beyond mere culture.
So they and their community, they were going by what they probably considered their objective morality.
We know that was subjective morality because we know that that is objectively wrong.
So just keep holding on to that.
And we could go deeper than this, but we’ll probably save that for the newsletter.
Part 4: The Cheating Problem
Imagine someone wants to cheat, right?
We talked about this.
Evolution may help explain the desire.
Cheating could benefit me, right?
But where does the feeling come from?
I ought not to cheat even if I can benefit.
So desire and obligation are different questions here.
We’ve already touched on culture being the root of morality.
So let’s talk about what evolution describes and then we’ll wrap this up.
Evolution Describes, It Doesn’t Command
Evolutionary explanations can describe how certain behaviors develop.
But description is not obligation.
So humans evolved to behave this way.
That does not automatically mean humans ought to behave this way.
Part 5: What Does the Bible Say About Morality?
So to tie this all together, right?
What does the Bible say on this?
Because we always bring it back to the Bible.
The Bible grounds morality in God.
God is the source of moral truth. Human beings are accountable to him.
And this is why I believe it’s very important to ground your morality in the creator which I believe is the biblical God.
Because if you don’t then it’s sort of just left open to interpretation, right?
Which depending on the community you’re in, the group you’re in, that could change and you just want to be careful about those things.
Romans 2:15 — The Law Written on Our Hearts
Romans 2:15, what does it say?
Describes conscience.
People can recognize moral law written on their hearts.
So Christians realize that morality is based on something else entirely, right?
God created men and women in his image.
Genesis 1:27 tells us this, too.
Because of this, we have an internal law that tells us what is right and what is wrong.
What did Paul say in Romans 2:14 before we wrap this up?
When Gentiles who do not have the law do by nature what the law requires, they show that the law is written on their heart.
So when the Gentiles did not have the law, they do by their nature what the law requires.
They did not know the law or have the law.
But they’re still doing what is right.
That law is written on their hearts.
Why is that law written on their hearts?
This is the deeper question, right?
This is where we would go deeper into philosophical talking about God even deeper which I will do a little bit in the newsletter as well for you.
But think about that and what would the answer be there?
You would have to go back to creation, right?
And then you’d get into is there a creator?
Did the universe just exist?
If the universe just existed, where did the laws come from?
How did these things get written on man’s heart?
How were we able to know these things, right?
Without an intelligence, who programmed these things?
All questions that we discuss in depth here.
Made in the Image of a Loving God
So it is a known fact that various societies around the world hold similar basic morals.
We instinctively know that murder is wrong and this is true in many cultures.
We feel a certain degree of empathy towards others as we are made in the image of a loving God.
Right?
This explains what evolution cannot explain.
Why we feel this internal law of right and wrong.
So again, evolutionists, atheists can’t really explain this.
Now, you could argue and flip that right back and say, “Well, that’s just God of the gaps, right?”
And that’s just the general thing that can be said.
But yeah, you could say it’s God of the gaps. You’re just putting God in there.
But remember for the sake of what we’re talking about here with evolution and morality if we take that further and you should go further with that, you would go back to creation and understand who created.
And when you understand that creation, when your beliefs on creation are a creator and God is the creator then everything can stem down from that.
And it’s not God of the gaps because of who the creator is in the beginning.
What Did We Learn? — Recap
Instinct versus ought: The instinct to be moral cannot be explained via evolution or culture. So evolution culture can’t explain that.
Survival relativity: If morality was explained through evolution then it would be relative to one’s survival.
Cultural relativity: If morality was explained through culture then it would be relative to one’s society.
Universal feeling: The feeling of objective morality is found in all men and women everywhere in all cultures.
Image of God: God created us in his image, which is why we feel that certain things are objectively right or wrong.
So we’re going to stop it there.
Find links in the description for everything we discussed.
You’ll find a resources link in there now that will take you to everything that is available at any given time from commentaries, articles, some chat logs might be in there, different resources there.
Second thing is that you’ll find the newsletter link.
Subscribe to the newsletter. Put your email in. It’s free to subscribe.
That will send you our episodes to your email first of all, but second of all, there’s deeper resources in there.
These episodes here you’re listening to or watching are from those articles essentially.
So we’ll go a little bit deeper in there.
There will be some more deeper resources in there, some study guides, different things like that.
If you’d like to keep going, just click into the next episode in the playlist, and I will see you in the next.


Discussion about this episode