Share from 0:00
0:00
/

Why Atheism Fails to Explain What You Already Know

Atheism has a problem. It cannot explain why anything exists at all. The universe, morality, logic, and consciousness all demand an explanation.

This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Help This Ministry Grow...


LISTEN IN YOUR PODCAST PLAYER↗


The Cumulative Case: Exploring Logic, Fine-Tuning, Consciousness, and History

What You Will Learn

  • Why atheism lacks a foundation for logic and morality

  • How the universe’s fine-tuning points to a Creator

  • Why consciousness is a problem for materialism

  • How the historical evidence for Jesus’ resurrection is strong

  • Why the cumulative case is stronger than any single argument

  • What this means for your worldview

Why Atheism Lacks a Foundation for Logic and Morality

What is the basis for logic and morality in atheism? If the universe consists of matter and energy, how does that give rise to logic and morality? Logic is abstract; we experience it subjectively. It is not a physical entity that we can interact with. But something must be the case independent of our minds for us to be able to reason objectively. For example, $2+2=4$ is a true statement regardless of your beliefs about it. The same goes for morality. If God does not exist, there is no objective standard of good and evil. We cannot derive an ought from an is (David Hume). One might say, “Well, murdering children is wrong,” but that is merely an opinion. If humans are merely matter, then we are animals with a certain amount of intelligence. But how is that different from the most intelligent primate? The only difference between humans and animals is our spiritual dimension. Alexander Dostoevsky wrote, “If there is no God, everything is permitted.” He was right in that without God there is no morality, but most people recognize that certain things are right and wrong (murder, theft, etc.). This suggests the existence of a moral lawgiver, a maxim of which William Wilberforce wrote, “God’s law is written upon the hearts of men,” and the Bible confirms (Romans 2:14-15).

How the Universe’s Fine-Tuning Points to a Creator

The universe is fine-tuned for life to exist. The physical constants of the universe, if slightly different, would make life impossible. The probability of the universe’s constants being set by chance is incredibly low. Even the atheists’ best explanation - that there are an infinite number of universes, each with random physical constants, is pure conjecture.

Psalm 19:1 (NIV) says, > “The heavens declare the glory of God.”

Why Consciousness Is a Problem for Materialism

Everyone knows they are conscious. No one knows how consciousness came into being. We all know we have a mind, but materialists say everything is physical. Science can observe our physical brains, but it doesn’t explain our consciousness. Theism provides a good explanation for, as it says that we are created in the image of God (Genesis 1:27). We have minds because God has a mind.

How the Historical Evidence for Jesus’ Resurrection Is Strong

Jesus was killed, and his tomb was found empty by his followers. The disciples spread the message that he had risen from the dead and were willing to die for their beliefs. No one would willingly die for something they knew to be false. Something happened to cause the disciples to become martyrs. Jesus’ resurrection explains that something. It is the best explanation for how the Christian religion began. No other hypothesis adequately explains the origin of Christianity. The disciples couldn’t have been faking it because they were all in one place at once; hallucinations are not contagious. Neither could the body have been stolen because the guards were provided by the Jews and the Romans, who would’ve both wanted Christianity to die. All the evidence points to one conclusion: that Jesus was resurrected from the dead. 1 Corinthians 15:14 (NIV) says, > “For what we have is not the spirit of this world, but the spirit given to those who love God,”

but Jesus was raised.

Why the Cumulative Case Is Stronger Than Any Single Argument

There is no single argument that proves God exists, but collectively they form a strong cumulative case. They are similar to the arguments in a court case. You might not hear the defendant say, “I did it,” but a strong case is still formed with circumstantial evidence. That is exactly what the cumulative case is: circumstantial evidence that strongly suggests that God exists.

What This Means for Your Worldview

If the cumulative case for God is strong, what does that mean for you? If God is real, then you should care because he is your Creator. Your responsibility is to seek the truth. Romans 1:20 (NIV) says, > “For since the creation of the world God’s invisible qualities - his eternal power and divine nature - have been made known through what the world was created.”

What You Learned

  • Atheism cannot explain the foundation of logic and morality

  • The universe’s fine-tuning is evidence for a Creator

  • The resurrection of Jesus is credible based on historical evidence

  • The case for God is stronger cumulatively than it is on its own

  • It is your responsibility to follow the evidence wherever it leads


Resources from This Episode...

Discussion about this video

User's avatar